2023 Acura Integra Manual First Test: The Honda Civic Si for Adults
Pros
- Versatile hatchback form factor
- Zippy and fuel-efficient engine
- Uniquely positioned and priced within the segment
Cons
- Not necessarily better with the manual
- Unimpressive at the test track
- Can't escape comparison to the Honda Civic
Having now lived with and tested the new 2023 Acura Integra, we know it isn't a revival of the driver-focused, straightforward hatchback the internet commentariat yearns for. This may dismay Acura acolytes, and indeed we'd celebrate the arrival of such a car in our crossover-saturated market.
But don't forsake the 2023 Acura Integra because it doesn't meet your preconceived expectations. Even though it feels similar—perhaps too similar—to the Honda Civic Si, Acura sufficiently elevated the Integra to the luxury realm. It's a genuine rival to its European competitors, with some uniquely distinctive attributes. If you read on and discover it's not the Integra you wish it would be, well, maybe you need to grow up—the Integra certainly has.
How Quick? Not Particularly
One of those attributes—the one most crucial in this test—is its transmission. Automatics are prevalent among luxury subcompact cars, but choosing the Integra in A-Spec trim and adding the Technology package unlocks a no-cost option to swap the standard CVT for a six-speed manual gearbox. As in every Integra, it's joined to a 1.5-liter turbocharged I-4 that sends 200 hp and 192 lb-ft to the front wheels. In manual Integras, the power is regulated by a limited-slip differential.
Pauses introduced by clutch and shifter actuation are factors in the Integra's 7.7-second 0-60-mph time. All of its two-pedal rivals do the sprint in less than 7.0 seconds. Likewise, the Integra crosses the quarter mile in 15.7 seconds at 91.0 mph, trailing many of its adversaries in both metrics. Even so, the engine feels strong for its size, delivering a torquey surge on-boost that's accentuated by little wastegate whistles. What's more, its fuel economy rating of 26/36 mpg city/highway tops many of the 2.0-liter mills common in the set.
Manuals typically enhance involvement at the expense of outright acceleration, and the Integra's shifter justifies the trade-off. It moves between gates precisely and is weighted so it requires deliberation but not undue effort. Automatic downshift rev-matching is activated by default—don't worry, you can deactivate it, but don't knock it till you try it. The clutch is less tactile than the shifter; it's light and engages vaguely at the upper end of its stroke. In fact, it caught out a few of our drivers with unexpected wheelspin.
Fun-ish
The turbocharged, lightweight, manual 2023 Acura Integra embodies buzzwords that set enthusiast hearts aflutter. In most situations it's entertaining, moving with poise and pep that evinces the great engineering in its architecture. But the Integra is not a particularly sporty car, as proven by its test results and how it feels when driven hard.
A 60-0-mph braking distance of 123 feet is on the longer end in this category. Fade was generally a nonissue even under repeated heavy braking, but the pedal, soft at the top and requiring significant depression, doesn't seem tuned for dynamic driving. This setup disposes it to around-town use, as does the brake auto-hold function, which works flawlessly—not always the case in manual cars.
The Integra's 0.87-g skidpad average is about what's expected for the class, but the Acura's figure-eight time of 27.2 seconds at 0.63 g average doesn't impress, considering its rivals run the lap in the 26-second range. Our test team was frustrated by meddling traction control, which never seems to truly turn off and prevents full power unless the steering wheel is straight. Such interference negates the differential's benefit in on-limit driving.
Out on the road, the Integra is willing to play up to a point. Its tidy size and weight let it flow between corners, but the verve it initially presents evaporates if you ask too much of it. Instead, the Integra becomes overwhelmed by understeer and imprecision. Truly sporty cars come across as a vivid conduit between driver and road—the new Integra doesn't.
Our Civic Duty
At this point we'd be remiss to not mention how the 2023 Acura Integra compares to the Honda Civic Si. The chassis, powertrain, and amenities in these vehicles are largely identical, and perhaps unsurprisingly they drive very much alike. The shared shifter and clutch play a part in that. But our tests verify Honda's interpretation is the higher performer: It's quicker, stops better, and is grippier all around. Crucial to that are the optional summer tires equipped on every modern Si we've tested; all-seasons are standard on the Si and the only choice on the Integra.
Much more important than the Si's fractional test-figure advantages, though, is the fact the Honda is sharper, louder, and more direct—simply put, more fun to drive. At the point where the Integra falters, the Si stays hungry for the road ahead. It's remarkable how two vehicles so similar in hardware, performance, and general feel end up with such different personalities.
All Hail the Hatchback
This is not to suggest the Civic Si is necessarily better than the Integra. Aspects of the Acura make it more appealing than its platform counterpart, and—critically—cars in the luxury subcompact category.
Its hatchback format is high on the list. With a conventional small sedan, there will come a time when you'll size up its trunk opening, contemplating how you'll get some rather large thing inside. There's little such issue with the Integra: Lift the rear enclosure and revel in the big cargo area, made bigger by folding the second row. This setup makes Integra living realistic for anyone who carries bulky items or lifestyle gear. Its tall lift-over height is only a slight hindrance.
The luxury quotient is there, too. Adaptive dampers fitted on the Integra A-Spec bring a suitably smooth ride in Normal and Comfort modes and stiffen just so in Sport. Plush centers and firm, supportive bolsters make the front seats quite comfortable. Beyond a standard 10.3-inch digital gauge display, the 16-speaker audio system, wireless charger, and head-up display added by the Technology package qualify the Integra to run in today's luxury league.
Likewise, the cabin's layout and quality of materials are suitable for an entry-level luxury car. Yet the interior's similarities to the Civic are obvious. Acura could have done more to avoid such comparisons, particularly by distinguishing touchpoints like the steering wheel, shift knob, or infotainment system layout. But given how nice the Civic's interior is to begin with, how the Integra builds on it is no bad thing.
The same notion extends throughout the experience: that the Civic is its starting point bodes well for the Integra. If you recall, the Civic was a finalist in our 2022 MotorTrend Car of the Year contest, and we deemed it "one of the best vehicles on sale" in a comparison-test win. Most of the Civic's great things are present, if not enhanced, in its Integra transformation.
The Nicer Version of a Nice Car
Acura succeeded in creating a rival to starter cars from other luxury brands and offering a unique, practical vehicle to drivers who want something more upscale than a Honda. The Integra's pricing—slightly more than $30,000 to start and less than $40,000 in our fully loaded test car—undercuts the field by potentially many thousands of dollars to make it an undeniable value. It's luxury on the cheap that feels nowhere near cheap.
Yet even with its vaunted manual transmission, the Integra isn't the hot hatchback seemingly everyone across the internet insists it must be. That might be you. If so, accept the fact the Integra of 2023 isn't exactly like the Integras of yore. Time and progress ran their course, and Acura built a car that represents what it is now. If that's not enough, don't despair: This entry in the Integra tale is only at its beginning, paralleled promisingly by the reemergence of the Type S performance badge.
Looks good! More details?2023 Acura Integra A-Spec Specifications BASE PRICE $33,895 PRICE AS TESTED $37,395 VEHICLE LAYOUT Front-engine, FWD, 5-pass, 4-door hatchback ENGINE 1.5L Turbo direct-injected DOHC 16-valve I-4 POWER (SAE NET) 200 hp @ 6,000 rpm TORQUE (SAE NET) 192 lb-ft @ 1,800 rpm TRANSMISSION 6-speed manual CURB WEIGHT (F/R DIST) 3,040 lb (60/40%) WHEELBASE 107.7 in LENGTH x WIDTH x HEIGHT 185.8 x 72.0 x 55.5 in 0-60 MPH 7.7 sec QUARTER MILE 15.7 sec @ 91.0 mph BRAKING, 60-0 MPH 123 ft LATERAL ACCELERATION 0.87 g (avg) MT FIGURE EIGHT 27.2 sec @ 0.63 g (avg) EPA CITY/HWY/COMB FUEL ECON 26/36/30 mpg EPA RANGE, COMB 372 miles ON SALE Now Show AllYou may also like
Related: MotorTrend+ is the exclusive streaming home for Mecum Auctions! Sign up for a free trial today to catch all the action, plus the best automotive shows anywhere!Rare Blend of Power and SUV PerformanceNot Stock but not a Deal-Breaker
We've all known a Ford Bronco Raptor was coming, but nobody in the public Broncosphere has known for sure how Ford Performance planned to endow the Bronco with F-150 Raptor-worthy performance—would it do so using an EcoBoost V-6 (and if so, which one?) or a Coyote V-8? Well, now we know: The Ford Performance gang has worked its magic on the 3.0-liter EcoBoost twin-turbo V-6 from the Explorer ST, modifying it extensively to suit the Bronco Raptor's mission, which is to "reward the revs." (For more on the V-6/V-8 decision, head here.)That means the engine should produce meaningful power all the way out to the far reaches of the tachometer while the standard 10-speed automatic transmission's gearing ensures that power is easy to explore the top of the tach. Here's what it took to turn a family SUV motor into a desert stormer for a hardcore 4x4, plus the modifications needed to get that power safely routed to the ground.What's Under the Bronco Raptor's Hood?You'll recall that the 3.0-liter EcoBoost is basically a bored and stroked EcoBoost Nano family sibling of the compacted-graphite-iron-block 2.7-liter powering other Broncos, so it bolts in with relative ease. Relative to the Explorer application, this Bronco Raptor 3.0 features unique cylinder heads that eliminate the exhaust-gas recirculation and emphasize maximum air flow into and out of the engine.A giant high-flow intake airbox and filter drop air straight down into the turbos on each side, helping to reduce the overall restriction on the low-pressure side by 50 percent. The turbos themselves are new for the Raptor, and the plumbing to, from, and through the intercooler is improved to lower restriction. The combustion chambers flow more air, then aft of the turbos there is a full true dual exhaust system with 2.7-inch pipes and a new-to-Bronco four-position active-valve (Quiet, Normal, Sport, and Baja) that reportedly helps deliver a total drop in backpressure of 20 percent.The combined effect of all these mods is greater "boost durability," which means the boost sustains to enhance high-end power and prevents that feeling of power falling off a cliff as you near the engine redline. The new Baja drive mode also activates an anti-lag turbo calibration that further maximizes performance during high-speed desert running. As of press time, the team is still six weeks or so from finalizing the engine's state of tune and certifying it with the EPA, but we're assured it will make north of 400 horsepower. Considering this engine makes 400 hp at 5,500 rpm and 415 lb-ft at 3,500 rpm in the Explorer ST, we'd expect a healthy increase in peak power, probably at a higher rpm, with peak torque rising less but remaining available over a wider plateau.Driveline ModsIt takes a lot more torque to get a big 37-inch tire spinning than it does a 30-inch 255/70R16 or even a 35-inch 315/70R17 Sasquatch tire—especially if one tire ends up pulling the entire vehicle, due to locked axles and slippery conditions under the other three tires. Then there's the driveline shock that comes when a big, spinning tire suddenly finds traction and stops or slows upon landing from, say, a jump. To cope with these magnified driveline forces, both front halfshafts and both ends of the stronger front drive shaft get beefy constant-velocity joints—no simple universal joints here. The outer hubs and bearings are also strengthened.Following the torque aft, the rear drive shaft is also beefed up and it feeds a stronger new Dana 50 Heavy-Duty AdvanTEKrear axle (up from a Dana 44) made of thicker (9-mm) steel tubes capped at each end by a unique forging that helps widen the track. The differential is fitted with a bigger, stronger 235 ring gear (up from 220) and pinion, retaining the Sasquatch model's 4.70:1 axle ratio. Ford Performance developed both these axles and fits them to the Bronco DR race truck. They increase the track width by 8.2 inches front, 6.7 inches rear, relative to the Sasquatch package.Upstream of all this, the transfer case gets a stronger clutch for 4A automatic on-demand engagement, but it carries over the 3.06:1 low-range ratio and overall 67.8:1 crawl ratio. The standard 10-speed automatic is unchanged but for a revised torque converter and the addition of a second transmission oil cooler.Fearless Bronco Raptor 0-60 Time PredictionFord doesn't estimate acceleration times, but it says the base Bronco Raptor's curb weight should come in just under 5,750 pounds. If we conservatively estimate engine output at 430 horsepower, that gives a weight-to-power ratio of 13.4 pounds/horsepower. That's almost exactly what we measured on the last Ford F-150 Raptor 37 pickup we tested (13.3 lb/hp), and that full-size truck took 5.6 seconds to hit 60 mph on the same tires, with virtually the same transmission and a slightly taller axle ratio. So we're guessing the smaller truck will improve on that just slightly and lay down a 5.5-second 0-60 time, shaving at least a second off the quickest Bronco time we've measured.
ford escape-plug-in-hybrid Full OverviewBefore hitting the test track, we decided to take our 2021 Ford Escape Titanium Plug-In Hybrid up to a local mountain ski resort town, mostly for the drive back. It's satisfying to watch the hybrid compact SUV's available range increase as the regenerative braking system recovers energy. The phenomenon is enjoyed frequently simply because one is on the brakes quite a lot on a winding road coming down from almost 7,000 feet of elevation.Everything was cool (excuse the pun) until the faint odor of overheating began to waft into the cabin. Our regen system was evidently working overtime, at which point we decided to let the engine and physics do most of the vehicle's slowing. Still, we managed to take the Escape's EV range from nothing to nearly 20 miles (out of 37 max) just by using the brake pedal. Neat.Fuel Economy and RangeOur Escape Titanium PHEV test model is the top trim of a three-model 2021 lineup that also includes less expensive SE and SEL trim levels. Ford also offers a standard, non-plug-in hybrid that makes the choice a little tougher if fuel economy is your main goal.The Escape PHEV returned an admirable EPA-estimated 105 mpg-e combined, which leads a burgeoning small SUV plug-in hybrid segment that includes among others the 2022 Toyota RAV4 Prime AWD (94 mpg-e combined), 2022 Hyundai Tucson PHEV AWD (80 mpg-e combined), and 2022 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid AWD (90 mpg-e combined). Its mileage not unexpectedly surpasses the combined mpg of the regular Escape Hybrid, too, which came in at 41 mpg for the front-wheel-drive model and 40 mpg for the all-wheel-driver.Total range for the 2021 Escape PHEV is an EPA-rated 520 miles, and as mentioned earlier, all-electric range is 37 miles, which are both strong. But the 2022 RAV4 Prime—with its larger capacity 18.1-kWh battery and significantly bigger 14.5-gallon gas tank—beat that combined range by 80 miles. It also gets 5 more all-electric miles. The Escape's 14.4-kWh battery capacity and 11.2-gallon tank still help it get more total range than the Crosstrek Hybrid, which has the least amount of battery capacity of the foursome (8.8 kWh), and the Tucson PHEV, which has the smallest fuel tank (11.1 gallons).The Escape PHEV weighs at least 100 pounds less than the Toyota or the Hyundai and is only offered in FWD, two additional factors that help its efficiency—and help in other ways, as well. It gets its motivation from a 165-hp 2.5-liter naturally aspirated inline-four working in concert with an 83-hp electric motor to deliver a combined 200 hp.The RAV4 Prime and Crosstrek Hybrid have similar formulas, but the Toyota scales up while the Subie scales down. The RAV4 employs a 177-hp 2.5-liter inline-four and electric motors front and rear for a total of 302 hp and the Crosstrek uses a 137-hp 2.0-liter flat-four and two motors for a sum of 148 hp. The Tucson PHEV offers yet another method, a 180-hp 1.6-liter turbo-four for the front axle and electric motor for the rear developing a combined 261 hp. All except the Hyundai, which is outfitted with a six-speed automatic, are equipped with a CVT.What the Numbers SayBraking is one area where we see the Escape PHEV's mass working in its favor. In spite of a vague-feeling pedal, our test team found stopping power to be consistent, with the Ford SUV coming to a halt from 60 mph in an average of 123 feet, 4 feet shorter than the heavier Toyota. We have yet to receive test results for the Tucson PHEV, but a 2022 Tucson Hybrid AWD Limited we assessed averaged 129 feet.The Escape PHEV's steering was also unexpectedly communicative, especially for a modern hybrid FWD. That's where the Ford's dynamic strengths end, though."Power is just so-so, [and] as the laps added up, the [factory all-season] tires lost all sorts of grip, in both braking and on the skidpad," reports road test editor Chris Walton. Indeed, in our lateral acceleration and figure-eight tests, the 2021 Escape PHEV exhibited less grip than the 2021 RAV4 Prime and 2019 Crosstrek Hybrid, which was the last time we tested the current generation of each. As the plug-in Escape and RAV4 have similar setups and weight splits, suspension tuning and AWD traction likely also played roles.Straight-line quickness is also not the Escape PHEV's forte. It's swifter from 0-60 and through the quarter mile than the smaller, less powerful Crosstrek, but every hybrid is chasing the RAV4 Prime now. The Toyota snaps off 60 mph in 5.5 seconds and runs the quarter in 14.1 seconds at 98.7 mph, in each case more than two ticks quicker than the Escape. Our road test analyst Alan Lau put it succinctly: "[The Escape PHEV] is good off the line—and that's about it relative to the segment."What It's Like to Live WithFew shoppers will look at the 2021 Escape PHEV for driving pleasure. Practicality is the game here, and as the widest among small five-passenger SUVs, the Ford provides the most first-row space. But it's also not as long as the Tucson PHEV, which gives the Hyundai an edge in cargo space and rear passenger room.While the gas 2021 Escape is available in four trim levels, both the PHEV and Hybrid are pared to just three, the SE, SEL, and Titanium. Among the standard kit the range-topping model gets that the others don't are features like adaptive cruise control, a 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster, a 10-speaker audio system, and hands-free power liftgate. Our test vehicle also came in Rapid Red premium exterior paint and with the Premium package, which consists of embroidered floor mats, a head-up display, perforated leather, leather-wrapped steering wheel, panoramic roof, and a wireless charging pad. The 2022 Escape PHEV is a carryover except for three new exterior paint colors: Atlas Blue Metallic, Flight Blue Metallic, and Iced Blue Metallic.Poking around the cabin, we were slightly dismayed at the build quality in some spots. For sure, there is a lot of hard plastic, but that wasn't even the chintziest thing we found. The Escape PHEV's 12-volt battery is in the spare tire well under the cargo area floor and its execution seriously looks like someone did the relocating in their home garage. Furthermore, there's a noticeable gap between the steering column and the cowling beneath that's supposed to hide the wiring harness under the dash but doesn't.We might be picking nits, but if we were springing for the top model of any lineup, those are things that would give us pause. Fortunately, there wasn't much else beyond those details. The seats were comfortable, and the ride was smooth. The only way we could tell the powertrain was switching between gas and electric was by listening for the internal combustion engine's muffled hum. Otherwise, there was no sensation to tip us off.Driver controls were laid out sensibly, and the Escape PHEV's infotainment system was easy to figure out. Its automatic high-beam headlights were excellent on unlit mountain passes, and generally its driver-assist technology was unobtrusive and useful. In back, we appreciated how easy it was to fold the second-row seats and how they were nearly flat with the cargo area floor when folded.Before we handed the Escape PHEV's keys to our test team, we also went through the process of charging it up to see what that was like. It offers both Level 1 110-volt charging from a standard house outlet and Level 2 240-volt charging, which works with a high-output outlet like ones used for larger household appliances. We found a Level 2 public charger nearby, and after leaving the Escape plugged in for a tad over three hours, we got back 32 miles out of 37 in EV range.Had we left it plugged in for the full 3.5 hours we likely would've gotten a full charge. For comparison, Toyota claims its RAV4 Prime can charge in as quick as 2.5 hours on a Level 2, while both Hyundai and Subaru say the Tucson PHEV and Crosstrek Hybrid, respectively, can get a full charge on a Level 2 in about two hours.PricingThe base model 2021 Escape PHEV SE stickers for $34,320 and the Escape PHEV Titanium starts off at $40,130. When we added the $395 premium paint and $2,500 Premium package, that figure rose to $43,025.With the cost of the add-ons on our tester, the Escape PHEV still comes in under the range-topping 2022 RAV4 Prime XSE, which retails for $44,340, and the 2022 Tucson PHEV Limited, which retails for $43,775. At $36,770, the smaller 2022 Crosstrek Hybrid, which is offered in just one trim, undercuts them all except the base Escape PHEV SE, which is thousands less.VerdictThat trip up and down the mountain highlighted the plug-in Escape's strengths like its chassis' spryness and smooth ride (provided you don't push it too hard), its passenger space, and of course the strong fuel economy that a hybrid can return. Less impressive were its quickness past the launch, limited cargo space, and ubiquitous interior plastics.At its best, the Escape PHEV is the smart choice. You're saving money both on the front end and over time. It gives you everything you need, and on the range-topping Titanium considerably more. And as strange as this sounds, it's available all over the country (unlike the Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid, which is sold for dealer stock only in California at this time).But while the 2021 Escape Titanium PHEV is good in the areas that count, there is little to no premium-ness to this top trim. Even its jellybean shape is uninspiring and could use some harder edges. It's almost unfair that something as dynamically superior as the RAV4 Prime is in the same segment.That said, we don't think track testing results will make a ton of difference to most hybrid compact SUV shoppers. We do think a good deal will. And at the end of the day, if you're here to party in your small crossover, you better be ready to pay for it.Looks good! More details?2021 Ford Escape (FWD Titanium PHEV) SPECIFICATIONS BASE PRICE $40,130 PRICE AS TESTED $43,025 VEHICLE LAYOUT Front-engine, FWD, 5-pass, 4-door SUV ENGINE 2.5L port-injected Atkinson cycle DOHC 16-valve I-4, plus permanent-magnet elec motor POWER (SAE NET) 165 hp @ 6,250 rpm (gas), 83 hp (elec); 200 hp (comb) TORQUE (SAE NET) 155 lb-ft @ 4,500 rpm (gas) TRANSMISSION Cont variable auto CURB WEIGHT (F/R DIST) 3,974 lb (58/42%) WHEELBASE 106.7 in LENGTH x WIDTH x HEIGHT 180.5 x 74.1 x 68.6 in 0-60 MPH 7.7 sec QUARTER MILE 16.0 sec @ 91.6 mph BRAKING, 60-0 MPH 123 ft LATERAL ACCELERATION 0.79 g (avg) MT FIGURE EIGHT 27.7 sec @ 0.60 g (avg) EPA CITY/HWY/COMB FUEL ECON 29/36/32 mpg (gas) 117/93/105* mpg-e EPA RANGE, COMB 520* mi ON SALE Now *EPA blended-PHEV (charge-depleting) mode testing, with vehicles set to their default drive and brake-regeneration modes. Show All
0 Comments